Creality is renowned for its innovative 3D scanners, and the CR-Scan Otter and CR-Scan Raptor are standout models in their lineup. These scanners cater to a range of needs, from detailed small-scale objects to large industrial components. This comparison delves into the unique advantages of each model, providing a clear understanding of their features. Whether you’re a professional or a hobbyist, this guide will help you decide which scanner, the CR-Scan Otter or the CR-Scan Raptor, best suits your requirements.
CR-Scan Otter VS CR-Scan Raptor 3D Scanner
Accuracy and Precision
- Accuracy: Up to 0.02mm
- Resolution: 0.05-2mm
- Accuracy: Up to 0.02mm with Blue Light mode, up to 0.1mm with NIR mode
- Resolution: 0.02-2mm with Blue Light mode, 0.1-2mm with NIR mode
Analysis:
The CR-Scan Otter and CR-Scan Raptor both offer high accuracy of up to 0.02mm. However, the Raptor provides this precision only in its Blue Light mode, while the accuracy drops to 0.1mm in NIR mode. The Otter maintains its high accuracy consistently, making it more reliable for precision-demanding tasks. The Raptor's flexibility with two modes can be advantageous for different scanning scenarios, balancing between precision and broader applicability.
Scanning Speed
- Scanning Speed: Up to 20fps
- Scanning Speed: Up to 60fps with Blue Light mode, up to 20fps with NIR mode
Analysis:
The CR-Scan Raptor outperforms the Otter significantly in scanning speed, reaching up to 60fps in Blue Light mode. This makes it much faster for capturing high-detail scans in less time. The Otter's speed of 20fps is adequate for many applications but may not be sufficient for rapid or large-scale scanning tasks. If speed is a critical factor, the Raptor has a clear advantage.
Object Size Compatibility
- Object Size Range: 10*10*10mm to 2000*2000*2000mm
- Object Size Range: 5*5*5mm to 2000*2000*2000mm
Analysis:
Both scanners are capable of handling a wide range of object sizes, but the CR-Scan Raptor has a slight edge in scanning smaller objects, starting from 5mm³ compared to the Otter's 10mm³. This makes the Raptor more versatile for applications involving very small details. However, both models can accommodate large objects up to 2000mm³, ensuring they are suitable for a variety of tasks.
Anti-Shaking and Stability
- Feature: One-Shot 3D imaging technology for natural stabilization
- Feature: One-Shot 3D imaging technology for natural stabilization
Analysis:
Both scanners are equipped with One-Shot 3D imaging technology, which provides natural stabilization and reduces tracking loss. This feature ensures smooth and efficient scanning, particularly in handheld scenarios. There's no significant difference between the two models in this regard, as both offer reliable anti-shaking capabilities.
Scanning Black and Metal Objects
- Capability: Scans black and metal objects without spraying
- Capability: Scans black and metal objects without spraying
Analysis:
Both the CR-Scan Otter and CR-Scan Raptor can scan black and metal objects without the need for spraying, making them suitable for automotive and industrial applications where these materials are common. This feature ensures accurate scanning without additional preparation, saving time and effort.
Full-Color Scanning
- Feature: 24-bit Full-Color Scanning with RGB camera and exclusive color mapping algorithm
- Feature: 24-bit Full-Color Scanning with 12 circular LED texture lights
Analysis:
Both scanners offer 24-bit full-color scanning, which ensures detailed and vibrant color reproduction. The Otter uses a full-color RGB camera with a color mapping algorithm, while the Raptor enhances brightness with 12 circular LED texture lights. Both approaches are effective, but the Raptor's additional lighting can be particularly useful in darker environments.
Portability and Ease of Use
- Weight: 390g
- Dimensions: 165*37*59mm
- Software: CrealityScan with user-friendly features and step-by-step tutorials
- Weight: 372g
- Dimensions: 215*50*74mm
- Calibration: High-precision glass calibration board
Analysis:
Both models are lightweight and portable, making them easy to use in various settings. The Otter is slightly heavier but still highly portable. The Raptor includes a high-precision glass calibration board, which helps maintain accuracy over time. The Otter's software is noted for its user-friendliness, which can be a significant advantage for beginners or those who prefer straightforward operation.
Conclusion
The CR-Scan Otter and CR-Scan Raptor each have their strengths. The Otter excels in consistent high accuracy, user-friendly software, and versatility in scanning different object sizes. The Raptor stands out with its higher scanning speed, dual-mode flexibility, and slightly better capabilities for very small objects. Depending on your specific needs—whether you prioritize speed, precision, or ease of use—either scanner could be an excellent choice for your 3D scanning projects.
